Naked 3 Eyeshadow Palette Dupe?

Friday, 18 April 2014

Oh look it's my first makeup review post of 2014....and it's nearly the end of April. I should really stop calling myself a beauty blogger. Anyway, I'm sure you'll forgive me when you see what an absolute BARGAIN I have to share with you.

A week or so ago I saw HelloTerriLowe post a tweet about a Revolution eyeshadow palette that she was loving. I'd never heard of Revolution before so I gave the link a wee click out of curiousity and my first thought was "ooh those colours look a bit like the Naked 3 palette". My second thought was "£4?!!!" and within about 5 minutes it was in my basket.

Now a quick disclaimer - I know I've called this post "Naked 3 Dupe" and I am pretty confident that it IS a great dupe, but I don't actually own the Naked 3 palette so you know, don't quote me on it.

Having read a ton of Naked 3 reviews and seen like a million arm swatches I feel like I have a pretty decent idea of what the shades look like though, and I can tell you that the Revolution Iconic 3 palette shades are almost identical. When reviews of Naked 3 started springing up last year I was so tempted to buy it as I immediately fell in love with the pinky/bronzey shades, but the reason I didn't give in was that I put my sensible hat on and told myself that while those colours are really "in" right now, I probably won't still be loving them in 6 months time. So that's why finding an alternative which gives me the same result for a price I don't feel guilty about was like a beauty dream come true.

Btw the Naked 2 palette though is a different story - this one I did actually willingly shell of £30-odd for about a year ago and still use on a weekly basis. If you're looking for a versatile palette with a mix of light and dark, shimmery and matte shades that will work for day-to-day as well as dramatic night-out looks, then Naked 2 is perfect. I don't feel guilty about that one at all, but I'm almost certain that I would have had a major case of buyers remorse if I'd given in to the Naked 3 hype.

Comparing Revolution Iconic 3 and Urban Decay Naked 3

Anyway, on with the review! First up let's look at the packaging - now obviously this is where you can see the biggest difference between the premium and cheap product. The Naked palettes come in really fancy looking tins with a mirror on the inside, whilst the Revolution palette is a basic plastic see-through container with no mirror. If having pretty packaging is something that bothers you then this might put you off the Revolution palette, but I couldn't care less (and for £4 neither should you).


I've already discussed the fact that the shades look almost identical above and I've photographed some swatches below so you can see for youself. Like I said, I don't have the Naked 3 palette so can't show you side by side comparisons, but you get the drift.  The fact that they've called the palette Iconic 3 is a pretty big hint that they've based this on Naked 3 too (their Iconic 1 and Iconic 2 palettes look like attempted dupes of the other Naked palettes).


Again, as the Revolution product is cheaper you'd expect that the quality isn't as good as an Urban Decay product and there is definitely more fall-out than I get with my Naked 2 shades, but that's nothing a good dusting of loose powder won't fix. In fact, when I'm doing a particularly heavy eye or using glittery shadows I generally do my eye makeup first so I can clean off any fallout before applying foundation (tip alert).  Apart from fall-out I don't feel like there is a massive difference in quality though to be honest, the Revolution shadows still feel quite creamy and the pigmentation is great.


If you're bothered about makeup ingredients then yeah again this is something that might put you off the Revolution palette as there are a lot of letter/number ingredients in the list which isn't the best sign, but I've been using the eyeshadows every day for the past week and a half and haven't had any problems with irritation or anything so far.

Finally, the biggest difference beween the two is obviously the price. Naked 3 is £37 on average whilst the Revolution Iconic 3 is just £4.


Four British Pounds. 

The whole palette is cheaper than the bottle of micellar water I'd use to remove it.

What a bloody bargain.

If you've been toying with the idea of buying the Naked 3 palette then I definitely recommend trying this first. At almost 1/10 of the price you can't really go wrong.


What do you think - have you got Naked 3, does it look like a good dupe?

(ring* - rings & tings)

OOTD: Pastel Accents

Wednesday, 16 April 2014

dress - asos
belt - asos (old)
bag - asos
necklace - primark
love heart ring - gift
sunglasses & moustache rings - primark

The other weekend I got all dressed up for a night out for my pal Kirsty's birthday - we started off with cocktails at The Lioness of Leith and then ended it dancing to 90's indie classics at Citrus Club (which was filled with actual children).  I feel like I probably go on a bit too much on here about how much love I have for my Scottish Blogger pals so I won't waffle on too much - but I will quickly say that Kirsty is one of my favourite people and I am so happy that she has become a part of my life in the last year.  Emotional bit over......back onto clothes!

So as always seems to happen when I'm getting ready for a night out, I started off with TONS of time but somehow ended up rushing at the end so didn't really have time to take proper OOTD photos which means I'm stuck with this very short selection.  The dress was a new purchase from ASOS - remember how I won a competition last year and got a £200 ASOS voucher?  Well I discovered that I still had £40-odd left after I sent some stuff back, so I ordered a couple of dresses last week and this is the one I ended up keeping.  I love the crochet detailing on the top half, and it's a good length on me (if you're taller than say 5ft3 though then it would actually be REALLY short). 

I paired the dress with some pastel accessories, as I'm pretty obsessed with pastels at the moment (I watched a bunch of Primark haul videos at the weekend and made a list of things to look out for and literally everything was a pastel colour).  The necklace is Primark, the belt and bag are ASOS (yep, it's that bag again!), the love heart ring was a gift, and the other rings are Primark.  Oh and in case you're wondering the reason I didn't have my engagement ring on is because it's a tiny bit too big and I was worried that it might fall off when I was out dancing (plus you know, I could chat up men*).  I didn't photograph the shoes but I was wearing wedge heel shoe boots from New Look 915.

*JOKE obviously.

Since I was pretty rubbish at taking photos of the outfit, here's a couple of photos from the night out to make up for it!

lianne & laura

gillian, me, iona & gill

Battle of the Micellar Waters

Wednesday, 9 April 2014

Garnier are the latest brand to dip their toes in the micellar water market and as I mentioned in my recent beauty buys post I bought myself a bottle when I was in Boots last month.  I've been using it for the last few weeks and wanted to do a review but given that it's a bit of a DULL product to write about I've tried to do something a bit different.  Before the Garnier version came into my life I'd been using the L'Oreal 3 in 1 Purifying Micellar Solution pretty solidly for the last 6 months or so and still had some left so I thought I'd do a "scientific" (not really) experiment and pit the 2 against each other to see which was better.  

Ding ding!  Let battle commence!

Makeup removal
First up is arguably the most important bit - how good a job do they do at removing make-up.  The only reason I use micellar water is to take off my makeup before cleansing so ideally I want this to be as easy as possible - if I have to use tons of soaked cotton pads then I'm not impressed.  

To keep things fair I used one micellar water on each half of my face, that way they were both removing the exact same amount of makeup.  I used one cotton pad per eye, then one pad for the face, going over with a third to check if there was anything left.  There wasn't much difference between the two at this stage to be honest, with the third cotton pad coming back completely clear for both sides of the face.

Winner: Tie

I couldn't really find a good word to describe this next test so I've gone with "finish" - basically I tested how the product left my skin, did it dry quickly, did my skin sting etc.  I timed how long it took for the product to completely dry on the skin and surprisingly there was absolutely no difference between the two - both took 1 minute and 40 seconds to sink in.

The one difference though was that the L'Oreal version made my skin feel really hot on the cheeks for some reason - I have noticed that my face does sometimes feel really flushed after I've removed my makeup but hadn't actually thought it was anything to do with the product.

Winner: Garnier (purely due to L'Oreal making my skin flush)

Having used the L'Oreal cleansing water for the last 6 months or so one of the things that annoys me on a daily basis is the packaging.  The bottle LOOKS nice and as it's so slim it doesn't take up much room in my beauty drawer, but when it comes to putting product onto a cotton pad the flat top means that you get a lot of spillage.  It's pretty much impossible to squeeze some out without it dribbling down the side which is a pain in the arse.  The Garnier bottle has a much better design though so it's a lot easier to get product out (and also to decant into a smaller bottle for travelling). 

Winner: Garnier

Show me the money!  If I'm honest, price has definitely been the biggest influencer behind me buying L'Oreal  up until now, as it's significantly cheaper than the Bioderma version.  When sold at full price Garnier is exactly the same as L'Oreal BUT the bottle is bigger so you're getting more for your money.

L'OrĂ©al Skin Perfection 3 in 1 Purifying Micellar Solution - £4.99 for 200ml (currently on offer for £3.33)
Garnier Micellar Cleansing Water - £4.99 for 400ml

Winner: Garnier

So based on these super scientific tests....ahem....I'd say that Garnier is the clear winner!  In terms of makeup removal and the way it feels on the skin there's not a lot between the two to be fair, but Garnier definitely has the better packaging and you can't argue with the price.  This is one I'll absolutely be repurchasing.

What do you think though - have you tried both?  Can you recommend another cleansing water I should try next?

March Highlights

Monday, 31 March 2014
holidaying in copenhagen (read more here)

where we bounced on sidewalk trampolines

ate the best churros ever

explored castles and palaces

whilst wearing fetching blue shoe covers

and got engaged!

celebrating my birthday and engagement with my parents & tapas

bowling and cocktails with friends 

visiting the beautiful Cliveden House for work

more cocktail celebrations with B's family

drinking DNAquiris...

….eating liquid nitrogen ice cream….

….watching Kirsty and Iona do battle in a cream cracker eating competition….

…and playing with puns….

all at the launch of the Edinburgh Science Festival at Summerhall (tickets on sale now)